Skip to main content

The Finance of Startups: For Dummies (Part 9.5 – Examples of a Safe)


I wanted to continue on my last post considering the simple agreement for future equity (“safe”) by reviewing a couple examples of how a safe works.

As mentioned in the last post (Part 9 – Raising Funds through a Safe -- follow to understand the concepts), there are a few combinations safes using levers such as discounts and valuation caps (or cases with neither which likely includes an MFN provision). Let’s walk through a few examples:

Example 1: No Discount, Valuation Cap


Post-Money Valuation
Investor Invests in Safe
$100,000
Discount Rate
None
Valuation Cap
$5,000,000


Post-Money Valuation
New Investment through Series A Equity Financing
$1,000,000
Pre-money Valuation
$10,000,000
Fully-Diluted Outstanding Capital Shares
11,000,000

Here, the company will issue sell shares at $0.909 per share ($10,000,000 ÷ 11,000,000 shares). Thereby, the company issues 1,100,110 shares ($1,000,000 ÷ $0.909).

However, the safe investor from earlier will be issued shares at $0.4545 per share ($5,000,000 ÷ 11,000,000 shares). The per-share price is based on the $5,000,000 cap as it is lower than the $10,000,000 valuation from the Series A fundraise. The safe investor would then be issued 220,022 shares ($100,000 ÷ $0.4545).

Note: this assumes the company does not pay back any amount of the initial $100,000 safe investment.


Standard Preferred Stock
Safe Preferred Stock
Price Per Share
$0.909
$0.4545
Investment Amount
$1,000,000
$100,000
Series A Preferred Stock Issued
1,100,110
220,022

Example 2: No Discount, Valuation Cap


Post-Money Valuation
Investor Invests in Safe
$100,000
Discount Rate
None
Valuation Cap
$4,000,000


Post-Money Valuation
New Investment through Series A Equity Financing
$600,000
Pre-money Valuation
$3,000,000
Fully-Diluted Outstanding Capital Shares
12,500,000

Here, the company will issue sell shares at $0.24 per share ($3,000,000 ÷ 12,500,000 shares). Thereby, the company issues 2,500,000 shares ($600,000 ÷ $0.24).

However, the safe investor from earlier will be issued shares at $0.24 per share ($3,000,000 ÷ 12,500,000 shares). The per-share price is based on the $3,000,000 valuation as it is lower than the $4,000,000 cap. The safe investor would then be issued 416,666 shares ($100,000 ÷ $0.24).

Note: this assumes the company does not pay back any amount of the initial $100,000 safe investment.


Standard Preferred Stock
Safe Preferred Stock
Price Per Share
$0.24
$0.24
Investment Amount
$600,000
$100,000
Series A Preferred Stock Issued
2,500,000
416,666

Example 3: Discount, No Valuation Cap


Post-Money Valuation
Investor Invests in Safe
$20,000
Discount Rate
80%
Valuation Cap
None


Post-Money Valuation
New Investment through Series A Equity Financing
$400,000
Pre-money Valuation
$2,000,000
Fully-Diluted Outstanding Capital Shares
10,500,000

Here, the company will issue sell shares at $0.19 per share ($2,000,000 ÷ 10,500,000 shares). Thereby, the company issues 2,105,263 shares ($400,000 ÷ $0.19).

However, the safe investor from earlier will be issued shares at $0.152 per share ($5,000,000 ÷ 11,000,000 shares = $0.19 per share * 80% discount). Notice that the price-per-share must be discounted to arrive at a discounted price-per-share. The safe investor would then be issued 131,578 shares ($20,000 ÷ $0.152).

Note: this assumes the company does not pay back any amount of the initial $20,000 safe investment.


Standard Preferred Stock
Safe Preferred Stock
Price Per Share
$0.19
$0.152
Investment Amount
$400,000
$20,000
Series A Preferred Stock Issued
2,105,263
131,578

Example 4: Discount, Valuation Cap


Post-Money Valuation
Investor Invests in Safe
$100,000
Discount Rate
85%
Valuation Cap
$8,000,000


Post-Money Valuation
New Investment through Series A Equity Financing
$1,000,000
Pre-money Valuation
$10,000,000
Fully-Diluted Outstanding Capital Shares
11,000,000

Here, the company will issue sell shares at $0.909 per share ($10,000,000 ÷ 11,000,000 shares). Thereby, the company issues 1,100,110 shares ($1,000,000 ÷ $0.909).

However, the safe investor from earlier will be issued shares at $0.72727 per share calculated by the minimum of:

  • Valuation Cap: $8,000,000 valuation cap ÷ 11,000,000 shares = $0.72727 per share.
  • Discount: $10,000,000 full valuation ÷ 11,000,000 shares = $0.909 per share × 85% discount = $0.77265
Thus, the minimum price-per-share is $0.72727. The safe investor would be issued 137,500 shares ($100,000 ÷ $0.72727).

Note: this assumes the company does not pay back any amount of the initial $100,000 safe investment.


Standard Preferred Stock
Safe Preferred Stock
Price Per Share
$0.909
$0.72727
Investment Amount
$1,000,000
$100,000
Series A Preferred Stock Issued
1,100,110
137,500

And...

You can find more examples on the Safe primer by the Y Combinator team here.

What questions do you have about safes? How do you view safes to be advantageous for both entrepreneur and investor?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

You Make Time for What (and Who) Matters

I’ve always been a big proponent that you make time for the things and people that matter. Sounds simple, right? Then, why do so many not implement this better in their lives? Let me take a moment to recognize this more explicitly.
I touched on Laura Vanderkam’s TED Talk “How to Gain Control of Your Free Time” in last week’s post. In it, she shares a story of a woman who had a leak in her home. Coordinating with plumbers, and getting everything resolved, the woman estimated that it probably took seven hours of attention. That’s seven hours of “stuff” the woman hadn’t planned on doing. If you were to ask her (or most anyone) to find seven hours in the week before, she’d have told you, “heck, no, I don’t have seven hours. I’m busy!”
I was thinking of Laura’s talk in conjunction with Jacob Christensen’s How Will You Measure Your Life. Specifically, I’m aligning “making time” with Christensen’s Resources-Processes-Priorities framework. We make (process) time (resources) for the things th…

Leadership Take-Aways from Two of NCAA’s Most Successful Coaches

On my recent Delta flight, I read an interesting leadership article in Delta’s Sky magazine – the feature piece being an interview of two of the NCAA’s most successful coaches – Coach MikeKrzyzewski (Coach “K”) of Duke’s men’s basketball team and Coach Urban Meyer of Ohio State football with five and three national championships, respectively.
Given these two coaches’ storied careers, their leadership has incredible sustainability. Here are my take-aways from the article: Both coaches took leave of absences in their careers due to medical concerns. Their successes cultivated deeper motivations to win exacting significant physical, mental, social, and emotional tolls. After stepping away, however, each returned to coaching posts to continue winning ways, but implemented mechanisms and understanding to keep themselves in check. Take-away: To operate in peak form like their respective teams, leaders, too, need to ensure self-maintenance.The interviewer asked the coaches about social medi…

My Life-Defining Moment Happened When I Failed to Make Varsity in High School

Ever stop to think about who you are? What makes you tick and tock? How about what you truly enjoy and what you’re good at vs. not good at? Or what/ who has shaped you into the person you are today?
I’m at this stage of figuring out whether to continue independent consulting while iterating on ideas for the next startup or take on some full-time employment (consulting, product management, or otherwise). My recent post about my daily/ weekly schedule was an interesting exercise in stepping back and recognizing what I’m actually doing in a day, and made me really think at the macro level.
In one of my recent reflections, I thought about defining moments in my life. One of those watershed events that truly transformed me was my failure to make the Varsity soccer team in high school. I won’t rehash the whole story here – shared the story almost a year ago in my post titled “Getting Through Dark Moments and the Most Vulnerable Story I've Ever Told Publicly”. It’s this moment that I w…